TL;DR
When residents send in requests written by AI, staff at Perth and Kinross Council print them off and mark them up by hand with highlighters to work out what is being asked, the council’s data protection officer told councillors, The Courier reported on 19 November. Jillian Walker said AI is helping to drive an “extraordinary” rise in complaints, data requests and FoI requests. Subject access requests alone have doubled in two years, partly because of AI.
Wading through the output
Walker told the council’s scrutiny committee that a councillor’s suggestion of using the council’s own AI to sift AI-written messages had been overtaken by something simpler. “It sounds very low-tech,” she said, but the printouts had proved the most useful way to reach the core of a request. She said staff had more than once returned information to people who then denied asking for it, unaware of what their own request said.
Lisa Simpson, who heads the council’s legal and governance team, said AI lets people produce requests of ten pages or more instantly, and that 80% of such text turns out to be “nonsensical”. Her advice to the public was blunt: “don’t use AI if you genuinely want information”. Many requests were genuine, she added, and the most abusive go to the police.
AI is not the only pressure. Much of the rise is linked to Scotland’s Redress Scheme for people abused as children in care, which means staff process thousands of pages of distressing records. Walker said compliance on subject access requests improved over the past year but was unlikely to hold as the workload grows.
What the ICO says
The council’s experience lines up with guidance the Information Commissioner’s Office published on 11 November on AI-assisted subject access requests. The ICO acknowledges such requests can be long, repetitive, unclear or inaccurate, and may cite irrelevant law or invented case law. But it is clear that using AI does not make a request invalid, and that organisations must treat it like any other. Organisations can seek clarification, take longer over complex requests, or consider whether a request is “manifestly unfounded or excessive”. The ICO also suggests inviting people to check an AI-drafted request before they send it.
Looking forward
Perth and Kinross is the latest public body to describe the problem, after councils, schools and police reported a rise in AI-written complaints. In our view, Simpson’s plea is understandable but sits awkwardly with the ICO’s position: people are entitled to use AI, so the practical answer is clearer request forms and quick clarification, not discouragement.