TL;DR

NHS England has removed a web page naming 137 hospital trusts as “live” with Palantir’s federated data platform (FDP) and “realising benefits” from it, the Guardian reported on 12 November. The list went after 29 of those trusts said the platform was not live for them or that they used none of its applications. A shorter page now speaks only of early users seeing “real results”.

The deletion follows the Guardian’s reporting of freedom of information replies gathered by the campaign group Medact, which sent requests to every English hospital trust and every integrated care board. We covered those 29 replies on 3 November. The statistics watchdog, the OSR, has said it is examining the NHS claims about how widely the system is used.

Pressure on the numbers

This is the second time an FDP claim has drawn the regulator’s attention. The OSR had already told NHS England it had no evidence for the claim that the platform helped deliver over 100,000 additional operations.

Ben Coleman, a Labour member of the Commons health committee, called the listing “troubling”. “When NHS England makes claims like this without checking them, it destroys trust – and it has happened before,” he said, warning that the overclaim “could put more hospitals off using the FDP”. He wants the NHS to replace Palantir with an open health data platform that trusts and British firms can build on.

Medact spokesperson Rhiannon Mihranian Osborne, who works as an NHS doctor, welcomed the removal but asked why NHS England had spent years relying on “shaky evidence”. NHS England gave the Guardian no comment.

The contract decision

The timing is awkward. Ministers are weighing a two-year extension of the £330m deal, taking it to 2029, and reports in early November said they intended to grant it. Tom Watson, the Labour peer, now lobbies full time for Palantir and has written to Yvette Cooper, the health secretary. Separately, the company lobbied a former minister over WhatsApp about GP records.

Opponents are organised. Unison’s general secretary, Andrea Egan, said an extension would be “completely unacceptable”. A coalition of Medact, Just Treatment, Amnesty UK and Doctors Association UK has sent a letter to Cooper and to Andy Burnham, the prime minister. They argue the contract’s “termination assistance period” would let trusts move off Palantir safely in 2027, rather than two more years of embedding. Palantir says ending the deal would be “putting politics above patients”.

Looking Forward

In our view, deleting the list without publishing a corrected one leaves the question open rather than settled. Ministers face an extension decision with no public count of which trusts use which FDP tools. For UK public bodies buying AI, the lesson is to define adoption before announcing it: a connection is not the same as use.