TL;DR
Wales’s Future Generations Commissioner, Derek Walker, has called for no new AI data centres to be approved until Wales has safeguards and national guidance, BBC News reported on 20 November. He wants the long-term effects of each scheme weighed first. Ministers answer that they favour a “balanced approach”, with planning principles promised before 2026 is out.
What the commissioner is asking for
Walker’s office exists to push public bodies to think about the long-run consequences of their decisions and to monitor compliance with Wales’s Wellbeing of Future Generations Act. He wants proof that this law governs choices about AI infrastructure, with a scheme’s economic, cultural, social and environmental effects tested before it gets consent.
“We cannot afford to make decisions about major new data centres without fully understanding the long-term consequences and involving communities directly,” he said, adding that the schemes “will place significant demands on our energy and water resources”.
Where Wales stands
The call follows ministers’ move to take the decision on a Cardiff data centre away from the city council on the eve of its planning committee, citing the “substantial controversy” around a proposal at a hospital park and ride. Developers are also eyeing a site in Gwynedd, on land between Y Felinheli and Caernarfon.
Enterprise Minister Adam Price told BBC Wales earlier in the week that the government is building a “Made in Wales” version of the UK’s Data Centre Covenant. He wants new centres built in places that already have spare power and grid connections, to head off objections over water and power. According to the BBC, the UK covenant says Britain needs 6GW of capacity for AI data centres by 2030.
A spokesperson for ministers said each proposal still has to clear normal planning and environmental rules, and that the benefits of investment must reach Welsh businesses and communities.
Looking forward
The promised update on Welsh data centre planning policy is due before 2026 is out. In our view, the commissioner’s intervention raises the bar for it: a framework that only steers developers towards grid capacity may not satisfy a watchdog who wants long-term and community effects tested before any approval. Until it lands, objectors to schemes such as Cardiff’s now have the commissioner’s words to cite.