TL;DR

Cambridgeshire Constabulary now has an independent panel of volunteer experts advising it on the ethical use of AI, the Cambridge Independent reported on 16 November. Set up by the office of Darryl Preston, the county’s police and crime commissioner, the panel has held its first meeting, which examined Citizen Assist, an AI reporting tool the force began piloting in September.

Its members bring expertise in policing and criminal justice, law and ethics, data science and AI, safeguarding, and information security. The commissioner’s office says the aim is independent advice and scrutiny drawing on several disciplines.

What the panel looked at

Citizen Assist gives the public another way to report a crime. It walks people through set prompts to capture the details, and control-room staff then triage and process each report. It does not replace 999, 101 or the force’s standard online form.

At the first session, members saw the system working and discussed transparency, safeguarding, public confidence and the integrity of evidence. Panel members said the safeguards and oversight around the tool gave them confidence, and praised the force for opening a working AI system to external review.

Chief Superintendent Sherrie Nash said independent challenge was “really important, particularly as we introduce new technology into policing”. Preston said people increasingly expect to report incidents online simply, and that new technologies such as AI need “transparent and accountable scrutiny” if public trust is to be kept.

Why it matters

The force has other AI and data work under way: Cambridgeshire is one of the three east of England forces in Palantir’s recent data contract, although the panel’s first meeting dealt only with Citizen Assist.

Looking forward

In our view, a standing panel that sees systems in operation is a stronger form of oversight than reviewing policy documents, and it gives the commissioner an evidence base when the force proposes new tools. Its value will depend on what it is shown next. A reporting assistant that feeds human triage is a relatively low-risk starting point. The harder test will be whether the panel is given the same access to tools that shape decisions about individuals, and whether its advice is published.