TL;DR

Evidence papers behind Scotland’s school curriculum reform contain fabricated references, misattributed quotes and links to ChatGPT left in footnotes, The Herald reported on 15 November. The errors were found by Edinburgh University education lecturer Brodie Runciman. His colleague Professor Lindsay Paterson called the discovery a “scandal” and wants the review halted and restarted. Màiri McAllan, the Education Secretary, has refused to pause it.

What was found

The problems sit in Education Scotland’s “background and evidence” papers for the curriculum improvement cycle, a reform The Herald says is costed at around £2.8 million. According to Runciman, some cited books and articles do not exist, one paper title was invented, a book review was treated as academic research, and quotes were attached to the wrong sources or to irrelevant claims.

Some errors are factual. One paper put the number of pupils taking Higher PE at more than 200,000; The Herald gives the real figure as about 11,000. One assertion, that social media can benefit “vulnerable” children, was sourced to a San Francisco Chronicle opinion column. Maths examples were wrong, and some errors appear in a draft technical framework that, Runciman says, teachers will use to plan daily lessons.

The affected papers cover subjects from literacy and languages to science, maths, health and wellbeing, and expressive arts. Runciman said that when he raised the problems, Education Scotland told him it did not plan to change “the underlying substance of the paper”.

The official response

McAllan said there was “no reason whatsoever to pause this important work”. In her account, AI did not write the curriculum documents; it was used only to “support the review, clarity and quality assurance” of papers exceeding 1,000 pages. She added that over 3,800 teachers, practitioners and experts have signed up to review the drafts.

Education Scotland pointed to a declaration on the papers stating that approved AI tools were used in that supporting role and that its own staff wrote the content. It stressed that the documents are drafts and will be refined with teachers.

Paterson’s objection goes to the evidence itself. “If evidence is fabricated, then the claim that the policy [of curriculum reform] is drawing on evidence is dishonest,” he said.

Looking Forward

The new curriculum is due in classrooms from August 2028. In our view, that leaves time to rebuild the evidence base, and the episode shows how fabricated citations can slip into official documents that are meant to be evidence-based. A declaration saying AI only “supported” quality assurance does not help if no one checked the references it touched.