TL;DR

Getty Images’ copyright case against Stability AI returned to court in the week of 9 November, this time before the Court of Appeal, CMU reported on 13 November. The record industry body BPI intervened on Getty’s side. It argues that last year’s High Court ruling, if it stands, suggests AI companies could train models outside the UK and still sell them here without facing UK copyright rules. A judgment is expected late this year or early in 2027.

What the appeal turns on

The dispute is now about secondary infringement. Getty originally claimed primary infringement too, alleging Stability copied images from its libraries to train Stable Diffusion. Those claims fell away because the training did not take place in the UK and Getty accepted that no copies of its images sit inside the model itself.

That left a narrower question. UK law can make someone liable for importing and commercialising an “infringing copy” made abroad, the rule normally applied to physical goods such as unlicensed CDs pressed overseas. The High Court decided the rule did not extend to the Stable Diffusion model. Getty wants that reversed. Stability’s lawyers argue that widening copyright liability in this way is a matter for Parliament, not the courts.

Why the BPI is involved

The BPI says the High Court’s reading could have “significant consequences” for music and the wider creative sector. But it also stressed the limits of the case. Because Getty conceded the model holds no copies of its works, the judgment says nothing general about whether AI models contain their training data.

On that point the BPI pointed to German litigation brought by the collecting society GEMA against OpenAI and Suno, where Munich judges found that models had “memorised” protected works. Harry Jewson of Burges Salmon, who has followed the case, summarised the BPI’s position as treating the Getty ruling as having “no wider significance” on memorisation, which is specific to each model. Our strategic analysis of GEMA v Suno looked at what the Munich Suno ruling could mean for the UK.

Looking Forward

The Court of Appeal’s ruling will be the most authoritative UK statement yet on whether models trained abroad can be treated as imported infringing articles. In our view, a win for Getty would push UK AI suppliers to document where and how their models were trained. A loss would leave the offshore question to Parliament, where the All Party Parliamentary Group on Music has already called for the law to be changed.